Skip to main content

The Cognitive Dissonance of British Politics

Margaret Thatcher “If you just set out to be liked, you would be prepared to compromise on anything at any time, and you would achieve nothing

The psychodrama that is British politics culminated in the swift downfall of now ex-PM Liz Truss in October, after only 45 days in office. Thus, achieving the title of the shortest serving UK Prime Minister in British history and ousting the previous holder, George Canning, who lasted 119 days before dying in office of pneumonia in August 1827. Arguably, her term may have lasted longer if her government didn’t follow Thatcher’s advice, and instead sought some compromise in the formulation of its ill-fated ‘mini budget’, which was founded on conflicting economic beliefs.

The astonishing turmoil that ensued during this 6 week period weighed heavily on UK assets, with the British Pound collapsing to a record low against the US Dollar, at one point trading towards parity at 1.04 US Dollars to one British Pound. The FTSE 250 index of smaller sized more domestically-focussed companies relative to the FTSE 100 index, declined -15% from mid-September to mid-October, whilst 10-Year UK Government Bond Prices (Gilts) declined -10% over the same period. This led to intervention by the Bank of England in the Gilt market to contain and stabilise some of the shortest sharpest yield spikes in the market’s history. The recent appointment of Rishi Sunak as the UK’s third Prime Minister in as many months, has restored some confidence throughout the UK financial system on expectations of a more coherent approach to combatting the cost of living crisis and restoring the credibility lost as a result of the Truss administration.

This does not come without challenges, the British public are experiencing rising costpressures with the Consumer Price Index currently at 10.1%, the highest since 1982, and in response the Bank of England have raised interest rates from 0.1% to 3.0%, the highest level since 2008, putting further pressure on UK mortgage borrowers.

The challenges are mounting for both UK households and businesses with the Bank now warning the UK is facing its longest recession since records began and expects a “very challenging” two year slump with the risk that the unemployment rate could double by 2025. Alas, there is a silver lining, albeit not that bright, the Bank has also signalled that its interest rates should not rise as much as markets are pricing in, partly because of the likely event of a prolonged recession but also implicitly because it does not want to cause a housing market crash.

Additionally, in an effort to stabilise the public finances of UK Plc, the Chancellor of the Exchequer, Jeremy Hunt, is set to announce a major economic package on November 17th with the aim of identifying £50 billion in spending cuts and tax increases. Further windfall taxes on energy companies are among the potential measures, along with adjustments to personal & corporate tax rates that should restore some credibility to the UK, but sadly for the British people, also usher in another era of fiscal austerity.

Cumulative Performance of UK Assets

Cumulative Performance of UK Assets

Source: Arbion, Bloomberg. Data as at 31/10/2022.

Equity Returns

Source: Signia, Bloomberg. Data as at 31/10/2022.

Global Equities: iShares MSCI ACWI ETF; Global Aggregate: Vanguard Global Bond Index GBP Hedged Fund; Global Sovereign: Xtrackers Global Government Bond GBP Hedged ETF; Global IG Corporate: Vanguard Global Corporate Bond Index GBP Hedged Fund; Global HY Corporate: iShares Global High Yield Corporate Bond GBP Hedged ETF; EM$ Sovereign: iShares J.P. Morgan USD EM Bond ETF; EM$ Corporate: iShares J.P. Morgan USD EM Corporate Bond ETF; EM Local Sovereign: iShares J.P. Morgan EM Local Government Bond ETF.

Equities

– Speculation that central banks may begin pivoting away from aggressive rate hikes led the S&P 500 to rise 8.1% in October, with value stocks (+11.5%) significantly outperforming their growth (+4.5%) counterparts. Energy & Financial stocks performed especially well rising 25% and 12%, respectively.

– Declining natural gas prices and a stabilisation in the UK political turmoil saw European assets fare well. The Euro Stoxx 50 rose 9.1%, whilst the more UK domestically-focussed FTSE 250 (+4.5%) outperformed the FTSE 100 (3.0%).

– Chinese markets diverged from Western equity markets as the Shanghai CSI 300 fell 7.7% as Covid-lockdowns remain stringent and continue to depress economic activity.

Jack Rawcliffe

Jack Rawcliffe

Senior Equity Fund Analyst

Fixed Income

– Global sovereigns finished in negative territory in October as interest rates spiked in response to market anticipation for tighter central bank monetary policy ahead.

– Investment grade credit generated negative returns and high yield credit turned slightly positive in October, with the former underperforming high yield credit due to higher sensitivity to rising interest rates.

– Emerging Market Hard Currency Sovereign debt did not move much on the month, whereas Emerging Market Corporate and Local Currency Sovereign debt indices were negative on the back of a stronger US Dollar, higher interest rates, and lower investor risk appetite.

Grégoire Sharma

Fixed Income Fund Analyst

Commodities & FX

– The decision from the OPEC+ group to cut production by 2mn barrels per day helped support oil prices in October, with WTI up +8.9%.

– The British Pound rallied against most major currencies as the new Chancellor Jeremy Hunt announced plans to fully reverse the ‘mini budget’, with Rishi Sunak also replacing Liz Truss as the new Prime Minister.

– After four consecutive positive months, the US dollar weakened in October, driven by weakening economic data and speculation the Federal Reserve will slow the pace of its rate hiking cycle.

Harry Elliman

Harry Elliman

Investment Analyst

World Economic Growth Rates (Real GDP)

World Economic Growth Outlook (Real GDP YoY %)

*Bloomberg Contributor Composite Forecasts, except IMF WEO for India. **Brazil, Russia, India, Taiwan, South Korea. Source: Signia, Bloomberg, IMF. Data as at 31/10/2022.

United States of America

Economic data continues to moderate, raising the probability of a recession over the next 12 months. Inflationary pressures are broad based, but many cyclical components are decelerating from their post pandemic highs. The Federal Reserve continue with their hawkish narrative and remain committed to prioritising lower overall levels of inflation. Despite expectation of smaller hikes at future meetings, Powell warns that the terminal rate is likely to end higher than is expected. The labour market is still running hot, but conditions are gradually easing, as labour supply rebounds and job openings slow from a record peak.

Eurozone

The ECB is also strengthening its resolve to combat the historically high inflation level of 10.7% with the Governing Council raising rates by 75bps in both October & September. Recession risks in Europe are primarily geopolitically driven, as high energy prices and elevated uncertainty are exerting a toll on the Eurozone economy.

United Kingdom

The turmoil felt throughout the UK financial system as a result of the “Mini-Budget” is fading with the appointment of Rishi Sunak, however, the cost-of-living crisis continues to weigh on the UK consumer, with inflation hitting the highest rate since 1982 at 10.1%. The Bank of England continues to raise rates to the highest levels seen since 2008, however, Governor Andrew Bailey notes that the prolonged recession will likely mean that rate expectations will fall short of market expectations.

Japan

Japan’s economic recovery has lagged other major economies and its long-term trend growth rate is amongst the lowest in the G20. Yen weakness worries some policymakers with headline inflation hitting 8-year highs. The central bank is notably out of step with its counterparts in North America, Europe, and Australasia where significantly tighter monetary policies are in motion, mounting substantial downward interest rate differential pressure on the Yen.

China

The Chinese economy continues to be weighed down by its ailing property market, which is experiencing its worst period on record, all exacerbated by the government’s zero Covid policies. Monetary (interest rate cuts) and fiscal (wider deficits and VAT rebates) stimulus continues. Unlike in western economies this year, Chinese inflation pressures have remained benign, leaving the People’s Bank of China as the only major global central bank to cut interest rates and ease financial conditions in 2022. The 20th National Congress of the Chinese Communist Party led to President Xi Jinping securing an unprecedented third term as China’s top leader.

Emerging Markets

A big driver of economic and market performance in EM and overall economic conditions in general is the strengthening US Dollar, which has so far in 2022 strengthened the most in a calendar year since 1984 (DXY Index). Inflation surprises in EM have turned more two-sided in recent months. Broadly, EM financial tightening pressures, which started earlier than many advanced economies, may possibly have peaked.

Important Information

The information set out in this document has been provided for information purposes only and should not be construed as any type of solicitation, offer, or recommendation to acquire or dispose of any investment, engage in any transaction or make use of the services of Signia. Information about prior performance, while a useful tool in evaluating Signia’s investment activities is not indicative of future results and there can be no assurance that Signia will generate results comparable to those previously achieved. Any targeted returns set out in this document are provided as an indicator as to how your investments will be managed by Signia and are not intended to be viewed as a representation of likely performance returns. There can be no assurance that targeted returns will be realised. An estimate of the potential return from an investment is not a guarantee as to the quality of the investment or a representation as to the adequacy of the methodology for estimating returns. The information and opinions enclosed are subject to change without notice and should not be construed as research. No responsibility is accepted to any person for the consequences of any person placing reliance on the content of this document for any purpose. No action has been taken to permit the distribution of this document in any jurisdiction where any such action is required. Such distribution may be restricted in certain jurisdictions and, accordingly, this document does not constitute, and may not be used for the purposes of, an offer or solicitation to any person in any jurisdiction were such offer or solicitation is unlawful. Signia Wealth is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.